A person wearing a bright yellow hoodie sits at a desk using a laptop, smiling and gesturing with their hands as if recording a spoken response to a video. They are wearing wireless earbuds. On the desk are papers, a calculator, a smartphone, a notebook, a coffee mug, and a small potted plant. The background shows a softly lit living space with shelves and decorative items.

When should you use VoiceThread? Choosing the right tool for media sharing and interaction

Best Practices, News, Resources, Teaching, Technology Trends, Tips, Web Tools

Video content can be an integral part of any course, but especially asynchronous online classes. How you share that content—and to what end—matters. There are multiple technologies available for sharing video content with students, and each has its own affordances. It’s important to select the right technology for the type of learning interaction you want students to have.

Some of the options for sharing video content with students at NIU include VoiceThread, Kaltura, OneDrive, and social annotation tools. Each of these supports teaching and learning in very different ways. Some options are appropriate for more passive video consumption, while others lend themselves more readily to an interactive experience. We’ll explore the affordances of each of these options, with a particular focus on VoiceThread, which was part of our Online Learning Tools Review and has moved to a more limited license, making it important that those who use it moving forward take advantage of its pedagogical capabilities.

When is VoiceThread the best fit?

VoiceThread is specifically designed to support asynchronous multimedia discussion centered on specific artifacts. It’s not designed for one-way delivery of video content. Unlike video sharing tools, VoiceThread allows students to respond using voice, video, or text in situ—on a slide, image, or document, or at a specific moment in a video. VoiceThread isn’t just multimedia commenting: it’s artifact-anchored, temporally and spatially contextualized discourse. Comments are not appended; they are embedded.

VoiceThread works best when:

  • Students need to point to something specific and explain what they’re seeing or thinking
  • You want students talking through their ideas, not just typing them out
  • The conversation should stay connected to particular parts of an image, slide, or video
  • Students are building on each other’s responses in a more back-and-forth, layered way
  • It’s useful for students to revisit earlier comments and rethink their ideas after hearing others

Because comments are anchored to the artifact itself and can include voice, video, and on-screen annotation, VoiceThread works well for visual analysis, peer feedback, narrated presentations, and reflective assignments where students need to show how their thinking develops in context.

How does VoiceThread compare to other tools?

The chart below summarizes how VoiceThread differs from Kaltura, OneDrive, and social annotation tools (e.g., Perusall) based on instructional purpose and recommended use.

Feature / Teaching NeedVoiceThreadKalturaOneDriveSocial annotation (e.g., Perusall)
Overall purposeSupports multimedia, artifact-centered discussionHosts and delivers instructional video (Blackboard-integrated)Stores and shares filesSupports collaborative annotation and discussion on video content
Interaction styleLayered, in-situ discussion using voice, video, text, and on-screen annotationMostly one‑way viewingNo built‑in discussionIn-situ, text-based annotation anchored to timestamps, with threaded replies
Student experienceResponds directly to specific slides, images, or moments in videoWatches videos; may answer embedded questions (for Quiz feature)Accesses shared documents and mediaAnnotates videos at specific points
Participation modelStructured interaction tied to specific mediaPassive consumptionIndividual access and file sharingDistributed, text-centered discussion across a shared artifact
Instructor roleSelects or creates media, embeds prompts tied to specific parts of the artifact, and facilitates discussion around student responsesCreates or uploads video content, organizes it for access, and may add quizzes or checkpoints to guide viewingUploads and organizes files, shares them with students, and may provide separate instructions for how materials should be usedSelects media, sets expectations for annotation and response, and guides discussion through prompts and occasional intervention
Best used when you want to…Have students explain thinking while pointing to or interacting with specific contentDeliver lectures or demonstrations efficientlyProvide access to materials or collect/share filesHave students engage closely with videos through annotation tied to specific passages or moments

How do I use VoiceThread to its full potential?

A laptop sits on a wooden desk displaying a course page in a learning management system. The course title at the top reads “Introduction to Women’s Literature,” and the page is labeled “Poetry Assignment.” In the center, a video player shows a slide with a split image of women in historical settings, overlaid with the title “Background Information.” Video controls and a progress bar appear along the bottom of the player. On the left side of the video is a panel prompting the user to choose a comment type, with icons for text, audio, and video comments. On the right side is a sidebar with tabs labeled “Ungraded” and “Graded,” along with a search bar. The interface uses a dark theme with navigation controls and an option to open the video in a full-size view.VoiceThread is most effective when it is intentionally designed around interaction, not just content delivery. Simply uploading slides or a video without structured prompts tends to result in minimal or superficial engagement. To use VoiceThread well, anchor your prompts to specific parts of the media. For example, ask students to interpret, analyze, or respond to something concrete, rather than responding generally. Also, require multimodal responses when appropriate. Voice or video comments can be particularly useful for explanation, reflection, or language use. Another affordance of VoiceThread is interaction, so build in expectations for students to respond to peers, extend ideas, or revisit earlier comments. It’s also helpful for students if their instructor models the kind of engagement they want to see. Early instructor comments can demonstrate depth, tone, and use of the annotation tools.

VoiceThread resources:

**Following the Spring 2026 semester, the Blackboard–VoiceThread integration will transition to limited access. Faculty who want to continue using VoiceThread need to submit a request form indicating how the tool supports their course design. This change reinforces the importance of using VoiceThread intentionally for the types of learning interactions it is designed to support, rather than as a general video-sharing tool. Faculty may also request to be removed from NIU’s VoiceThread license to use a Free Educator VoiceThread account. Contact us at citl@niu.edu to discuss this option.

How do I export/download my videos from VoiceThread?

A laptop sits on a wooden desk displaying a video assignment interface. At the top of the screen, the title reads “Poetry: Emily Dickinson and Edna St. Vincent Millay.” Centered on the screen is a pop-up window titled “Share Poetry: Emily Dickinson and Edna St. Vincent Millay,” indicating that the content is private and link sharing is off. The pop-up includes the heading “Save your VoiceThread offline,” with text explaining that the video is being exported and may take several minutes or longer. A circular loading indicator appears in the middle with the text “Exported 3 seconds ago” below it. A “Cancel” button is visible in the bottom right of the window. Behind the pop-up, a dark video player interface is partially visible, including a playback bar and timestamp along the bottom.If you have existing content in VoiceThread, you may want to retain local copies or move materials into other platforms such as Kaltura or OneDrive.

Faculty can export VoiceThread content, though the format and fidelity may vary depending on the type of media and comments included. Downloading is most useful for preserving original media (e.g., slides, uploaded videos), but interactive elements (such as layered comments) may not transfer seamlessly to other tools. All exported VoiceThreads are available in .mov format.

Key considerations:

  • A laptop sits on a wooden desk displaying a video assignment interface. At the top, the title reads “Poetry: Emily Dickinson and Edna St. Vincent Millay.” Centered on the screen is a pop-up window titled “Share Poetry: Emily Dickinson and Edna St. Vincent Millay,” indicating that the content is private and link sharing is off. The pop-up includes the heading “Save your VoiceThread offline,” with text explaining that the video has been exported and is available to download. A “Download” button appears in the center, along with an option to “Export again.” A “Cancel” button is located in the bottom right corner of the window. Behind the pop-up, a dark video player interface is partially visible, including a playback bar and timestamp along the bottom. Plan ahead—exports can take time depending on file size and quantity
  • Determine whether you need just the media or a record of the discussion
  • Review exported files to ensure usability before relying on them in another platform

Resources:

How can I move content from VoiceThread to Kaltura or OneDrive?

VoiceThread content is not directly integrated with Kaltura or OneDrive, so moving materials between platforms requires intermediate steps (export, download, then re-upload).

A typical workflow looks like this:

  1. Export and download your media from VoiceThread
  2. Upload video content to Kaltura if your goal is delivery or embedding in Blackboard
  3. Upload files to OneDrive if your goal is storage, sharing, or distribution

Resources:

How can I learn how to share videos using Kaltura?

A laptop sits on a wooden desk displaying a learning management system page labeled “Module 2 Lessons.” The main heading reads “Introduction to Gothic Literature (12:34).” In the center, a video player shows a dark image of a Gothic castle at night under a full moon, with playback controls and a timestamp bar visible. On the left, a simplified “Contents” sidebar lists literature-focused modules, including “Module 2 Overview,” “Gothic Literature: Origins,” and several subtopics. Under “Gothic Literature: Origins,” a selected item with a small multicolored Kaltura icon reads “Introduction to Gothic Literature (12:34).” Navigation buttons for “Previous” and “Next” appear in the top right.Kaltura is the university-supported platform for hosting and delivering video content within Blackboard. It is optimized for reliability, accessibility, and integration with course sites. If you share your video content via Kaltura, you can embed the video directly into your Blackboard course for inline viewing, add interactive elements such as quizzes, and track basic analytics on student viewing. Kaltura is the appropriate alternative when your primary goal is content delivery, not discussion or annotation.

Resources:

How can I share links to videos using OneDrive?

A laptop sits on a wooden desk displaying a OneDrive interface in dark mode. The page shows a folder titled “Engineering 101” under “My files,” with a list of video lecture files for an introductory engineering course, along with file sizes and sharing status. On the left sidebar are navigation options such as “Home,” “My files,” “Shared,” “Favorites,” and “Recycle bin,” followed by a “Browse files by” section. Centered on the screen is a sharing pop-up window for one video file, with fields to add a name or email, an optional message, and permission settings. The “Can’t download” option is selected, and buttons labeled “Copy link” and “Send” appear at the bottom.OneDrive serves a more basic, infrastructure-level role than tools like VoiceThread, Kaltura, or Perusall. It’s designed for file storage and distribution rather than structured learning activities or media-rich interaction. You upload a video, generate a link, and share it. There’s minimal configuration beyond access permissions. OneDrive simply provides a reliable way to host and deliver the file itself.

Resources:

How can I have students annotate a video in Perusall?

A laptop sits on a desk displaying a Perusall video assignment interface. At the top, the course title reads “Summer 2026 Intro to Literature by Women.” The main screen shows a paused film scene of a woman in period dress, with video controls and captions visible along the bottom. On the right side, a column of colored circular icons with initials represents different users, each paired with truncated annotation comments ending in ellipses. The interface uses a dark theme with the Perusall logo in the upper left and navigation links across the top.If your goal is to have students engage closely with video content through written discussion tied to specific moments, Perusall can be an alternative to VoiceThread—particularly when text-based interaction is sufficient or preferred. Perusall allows students to annotate videos at precise timestamps and respond to peers in written threaded discussions. It’s particularly useful for guided viewing assignments, critical analysis of video content, and surfacing questions and misunderstandings. Unlike VoiceThread, Perusall focuses on text-based annotation, not multimodal response. So, if you want students to engage in multimodal response, VoiceThread will be a better option for you.

Resources:

Bottom Line

In practice, each tool should align with a distinct instructional goal:

  • Choose VoiceThread when students need to respond to specific media, explain their thinking aloud, and engage with peers’ ideas in context. If the learning activity depends on hearing and seeing how students make meaning, VoiceThread is the appropriate choice.
  • Choose Kaltura when your primary goal is efficient delivery of lecture or instructional video and students do not need to respond to specific parts of the content.
  • Choose OneDrive when you need a secure place to store, share, or collect files, not to facilitate discussion or learning interaction.
  • Choose Perusall when your goal is to have students engage closely with readings or videos through text-based annotation, responding to specific passages or moments and building discussion in context.

In short: match the tool to the type of interaction you want—VoiceThread for multimodal discussion and interaction, Kaltura for delivery, OneDrive for access, and Perusall for text-based annotation and engagement.

Finally, when copying courses, review any integrated tools (LTI links) and remove those you are not actively using. Leaving unused links in place can confuse students and create unnecessary entry points into tools that are not part of the course design. It can also create support and data usage issues for CITL as we conduct future online tool reviews.

If you’re copying a previous course, ensure that all VoiceThread links are updated to use LTI 1.3 (Deep Linking) and test each link to confirm it functions correctly beginning in Summer 2026.

Need Help Choosing the Right Tool?

If you’re deciding whether VoiceThread, Kaltura, or another tool best fits your course goals, CITL can help. CITL staff can consult with you about learning objectives, interaction needs, and how technology choices align with your overall course design.

You can schedule a one‑on‑one consultation through the CITL website, attend a workshop, or explore CITL’s teaching resources for guidance on making intentional technology choices that support student learning.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email